What Do You think The Role Of Elected Officials Should Be?
I have long been a believer that the role of elected officials should be to enact policies that they believe to be the best ideas, not necessarily the policies that the people want. To this end I think we should spend less time worrying about their political stances and more time focusing on their ability to think, on their compassion, on their core belief sets. After all, what someone believes about the important issues of today don’t tell us much about how they will respond to the important issues 12 months down the road, but their character can tell us everything we need to know.
I say this because it is clear from recent polling that the majority of Americans are not supportive of the current Health Care Bill. This, of course, hasn’t stopped Democrats from trying to push this Bill through and I find that to be a little bit admirable. I don’t want a legislature that bows to the whims of the populace at every turn out of fear of not being re-elected. I ant a legislature that enacts laws they believe are in the best interest of the United States, even when I don’t like the legislation. Fact of the matter is, the legislators have more information about all of these ‘hot issues’ at their finger tips than every blogger combined. They have entire staffs devoted to researching topics.
So I ask, what do you expect from your legislators? Do you want a Democracy or a Republic? Should we send every American citizen a ballot for every law? Should law makers be obligated to vote in line with the majority of their constituency? I’ll end with a small excerpt from Alexis de Tocqueville’s Democracy In America:
“The people is always right,” that is the dogma of the republic just as, “the king can do no wrong,” is the religion of monarchic states. It is a great question to decide whether the one is more false than the other: but what is very sure is that neither the one nor the other is true.
Mr. Washington Smith told me yesterday that almost all the crimes in America were due to the abuse of alcoholic drinks. “But,” said I, “why do you not put a duty on brandy?”
“Our legislators have often thought about it,” he answered. “But are afraid of a revolt, and besides the members who voted a law like that would be very sure of not being re-elected, the drinkers being in a majority and temperance unpopular.”
Yesterday also another Mr. Smith, a very respected Quaker, told me: “The Negroes have the right to vote at elections, but they cannot go to the Poll without being ill treated.”
“And why,” said I, “is the law not carried out on their behalf?”
He answered me: “The laws have no force with us when public opinion does not support them. Now the people is imbued with very strong prejudices against the Negroes, and the magistrates feel that they have not the strength to enforce laws which are favorable to the latter.”










